Peer Review Process

Every submitted manuscript will be assessed by the Editor-in-Chief. Manuscripts that appropriate with the criteria of this journal, will be forwarded to the Section Editor for further processing. The manuscript will be checked for similarities or elements of plagiarism using Turnitin. If similar results are still large enough, the manuscript will be returned to the author for revising. When finished, the author submits the revised manuscript to OJS.

The Section Editor will assign a minimum of two reviewers for each manuscript, with the possibility of being immediately accepted with minor revisions, accepted with major revisions or rejected. The third reviewer will be assigned when there is a different decision between two reviewers.

The review process uses double blind review, meaning that the reviewer does not know the author identity, and the author does not know the reviewer identity. The reviewer will conduct a study and give considerations related to the suitability between the title, abstract, introducation, method, result and discussion, conclusion, and recommendation. In addition, the reviewer also give considerations related to novelty, scientific impact, and current reference theory. The review results from the reviewer are received by Editor Section and will be forwarded to the author, as consideration and suggestions for improvement. The author revises the manuscript according to the suggestions from the reviewer. When finished, the author submits the revised manuscript to Open System Journal (OJS).

The Section Editor will check the revised manuscript and give the final decision whether the manuscript is accepted or rejected, based on the improvement of the substance and the appropriate with writing guidlines of this journal.

The Editor-in-Chief with Section Editor will proceed the accepted manuscript to the editing and publishing process. Masjiduna will not guarantee or promise the acceptance of an manuscript or a very short review process to anyone. Every submitted manuscript must follow the peer review process, from manuscript submission until it is published.